Following a masterpiece is no easy task as subsequent albums will always be compared. That said, can Blue Sky Mining match the performance captured on Diesel And Dust?
Yes, and no!
Few would argue that both albums are exceptional in their own right, with Blue Sky Mining winning, amongst other awards, the Best Album of 1990 by the Australian Record Industry Association (ARIA). While I do consider Diesel And Dust to be the stronger of the two, both were released during Midnight Oil’s creative peak; that is until the release of RESIST in 2022.
While the previous paragraph never quite answered if Blue Sky Mining matched the performance of Diesel And Dust, I will say that it was Blue Sky Mining that would introduce me to one of the greatest rock bands Australia has ever produced.
I know, I still haven’t answered the proposed question, have I?
Perhaps it is best to say that the two cannot be separated or compared for whenever I think of Midnight Oil, I class both records as exceptional examples of what Midnight Oil is musically and what they stand for.
Known for their politically charged lyrics and energetic performances, Midnight Oil continued their powerful musical journey with this album and while the mastering isn’t quite as lush as that heard on Diesel And Dust, it is thoroughly enjoyable and allows one to turn the volume up without experiencing fatigue. That aspect is particularly interesting as the original releases of the album were significantly more dynamic but the brick walling applied here certainly doesn’t detract from the emotive energy of the recording. Dare I say, it enhances it for compression is not always a bad thing.
Blue Sky Mine launches the album with a driving rhythm and anthemic sound that perfectly suits Peter Garrett’s vocal style. Although, it is far from the strongest song to be featured on the album and the production is a little dated when compared to modern standards. Nevertheless, from the get-go, Midnight Oil showcase their social consciousness as they deliver their opinion on workers’ rights.
Stars Of Warburton slows the pace with a solid rhythm. While there is little doubt that Stars Of Warburton isn’t at the top of anyone’s favourite Midnight Oil songs, that chorus is where the magic happens.
Bedlam Bridge has a somewhat chaotic introduction that’s a little left-of-the-centre, but it’s compelling and draws you into the story and sonic wonderland that is to come. On Bedlam Bridge, Garrett’s vocals are amongst his cleanest ever recorded; unlike his earlier punk-era recordings. As with Stars Of Warburton, the chorus, with its infectious beat and catchy melody ensure that it’s not only memorable but is one of Midnight Oil’s greatest recordings. The only disappointment is the closing moments of the song as I feel the street sounds are distracting. Yes, I acknowledge the segue between Bedlam Bridge and Forgotten Years, but I feel the outro is unnecessary and should have been repositioned to the intro of Forgotten Years. It’s just unfortunate that I also consider the first few seconds of Forgotten Years to be the perfect length.
Forgotten Years is one of Midnight Oil’s most recognisable tunes and there’s little doubt as to why, as the band’s musical prowess, along with Garrett’s powerful vocals, combine with perfect synergy to form an exceptional tune.
Mountains Of Burma is evocative and is amongst Midnight Oil’s finest recordings.
King Of The Mountain has to be one of the most energetic, infectious, and hard-hitting rock rhythms in rock and roll history. There’s a little Punk, a lot of Rock, and Garrett’s commanding vocals. What more could one ask for?
River Runs Red slows the tempo considerably and very well could have been a Crowded House tune; that should be seen as a compliment. Sonically, River Runs Red is simply gorgeous. The musical layering is exceptional and is amongst the very best I’ve ever heard. It really is that good!
Shakers And Movers is a solid song, but I would class it as a B-side. However, a B-side for Midnight Oil, particularly at this point in their career, would be a hit for any other band.
One Country is another passionate performance with a powerful message from The Oils. Recorded with an acoustic focus, One Country becomes a contemplative listen that makes you sit up and take notice. It’s simply gorgeous!
Antarctica is a mesmerising closer. It’s thoughtful songs such as Antarctica that are Midnight Oil’s trademark, but it’s even more important as the final track on an album for you can either play the record again or sit and reflect on the music you’ve just heard. Whatever you decide to do next, one thing is for certain, Antarctica leaves a lasting impression.
Blue Sky Mining may not have reached the heights of Diesel And Dust, but it’s still one of the greatest albums Midnight Oil ever recorded. The higher production quality is noticeable, and appreciated, but it never sounds overproduced. Granted, fans of their earlier works may disagree, but you can’t please everyone. Nevertheless, with the album's powerful lyrics, energetic performances, and distinctive sound, Blue Sky Mining is a must-own, and listen, for fans and newcomers alike.