Released in 2014, George Michael’s Symphonica is a fluid masterpiece that melds exceptional live performances, captured between 2011-12, with studio mastery thereby ensuring the music and Michael’s vocal talents take centre stage with few distracting elements. With a collection of well-known covers, and a half dozen original songs thrown into the mix, Symphonica will captivate you from the very first note.
Some may lament the studio manipulation, but most live albums are created similarly. Truthfully, I prefer the additional spit and polish for live performances can be hit and miss and that’s a core reason why I’m not a fan of attending concerts. It’s a case of once-bitten, twice shy, and I prefer higher production values when live recordings are released.
Yes, dear reader, I’m one of those music lovers who doesn’t have a problem with artists using backing tracks at a concert if that’s what it takes to put on a good show. Is it pure and organic, no, but isn’t it better to have every note presented accurately than to have a substandard experience? I believe so!
The only aspect that I wish they had worked on a little more would have been the reduction of sibilance in Michael’s vocals. Michael’s vocal has always had a tad of sibilance, so I look upon it as artistic expression at this stage, but on a couple of the songs, it’s quite pronounced and temporarily takes you out of an otherwise relaxed experience.
Concerning the selection of songs, I find it incredible that Michael’s own works mix so perfectly with the classics of yesteryear. Seriously, it’s a seamless transition between tunes and goes to show just how incredibly talented Michael was as not only a vocalist but as a songwriter.
While I was fortunate to have owned the stunning HFPA (High Fidelity Pure Audio) Blu-ray release, following a culling of formats, I now find myself limited to the streaming offerings and I have mixed feelings. The DTS-HD Master Audio 24-bit/96kHz edition of the album, from the Blu-ray, was as close to having a private audience with George Michael as I was ever going to get and while I have few regrets about downsizing my collection; this is one of them.
The Dolby Atmos stream, via Apple Music, is admirable but it just doesn’t have the same presence as was heard on the physical counterpart. Interestingly, despite the Blu-ray format being capable, no surround mix was presented, yet, to my ears, it still had a greater presence. For many music fans, this won’t be an issue. For us audiophile-focused music lovers, however, it’s a substantial element for we strive to attain the best possible release. Nevertheless, I may have to try and seek out a vinyl edition, or hope for a reissue, as they’re incredibly hard to come by and go for insane prices on Discogs.
Symphonica is one release certainly worth owning but, as is often the case, it isn’t only a matter of sonic perfection for there are numerous releases of Symphonica, with different track listings, which makes choosing a definitive copy much more difficult.
For instance, the Blu-ray contained 17 songs, with the closer being You’ve Changed, as did the highly sought-after vinyl release, but the CD counterpart was abridged to 14 songs. The three songs removed were Roxanne, Going To A Town, and You Have Been Loved; all are exceptional performances and worthy of inclusion. Yes, incorporating these tracks would have gone beyond the limits of a single CD, but it would have been wonderful to have greater cohesion between versions by limiting the tracks, across all releases, to the finite runtime of the CD format.
Naturally, as a lifelong music lover, this should come as no surprise for it’s a constant problem within the music industry and a practice that I wish they would abolish for it would be far simpler if each version was the same so that fans don’t experience decision fatigue concerning which version we should pick up or listen to. Or worse still, feel compelled to pick up every edition; most likely the reason this is standard practice across the industry for the record labels’ ultimate aim is to make money and what better way to do that than by targeting the most dedicated of fans.
Nevertheless, you might suggest that given the Dolby Atmos mix is enjoyable, that this is the version I should enjoy going forward. I thought so too until I realised that the Atmos Mix and its stereo counterpart, both Apple Digital Masters, only contain the 14 songs from the CD release.
Confusing matters further, a lossless 15-track edition is also available via Apple Music (a non-Apple Digital Master). Where did that come from? Seriously, can’t we just have a definitive edition? This 15-song version adds I Remember You as the final track on the album. Interestingly the Deluxe Edition (also not certified as an Apple Digital Master) tacks I Remember You to the backend of the album.
It’s an absolute mess, isn’t it?
Still, for this review, I’m going to stick with the Deluxe Edition in its entirety, as all songs are featured, but while I consider the first 17 songs to be nothing short of perfection, I intend to remove I Remember You from my digital library for I feel it detracts from the highly polished production values heard throughout the rest of the album.
However, there’s a problem. Not a big one, but it needs to be addressed. The Deluxe Edition is not an Apple Digital Master. Few Deluxe Editions, by any artist, are and it simply makes no sense to me whatsoever. If the label goes to the trouble of remastering a release for the Apple Digital Master program, then why are the more complete editions omitted from this process? Surely it would be worth doing for those of us who appreciate the expanded offerings of Deluxe Editions.
Common sense, clearly, isn’t very common when it comes to what record labels do and how they manage their catalogs. I’m sure they’ve got their reasons for these discrepancies, but from a music lover’s perspective, I simply can’t comprehend why they make things so challenging.
I’m sure by now you’re wondering why it matters if the Deluxe Edition is an Apple Digital Master or not. Well, dear reader, it’s an issue for two reasons. The first is that for those who enjoy surround mixes, they should be able to get the complete series of recordings in Dolby Atmos. Secondly, and this applies more to me, I find that the Apple Digital Master of Symphonica is less shrill, more rounded, and therefore a little more enjoyable when directly compared to the non-Apple Digital Master. Despite that, given I want the same 17-track experience that the Blu-ray and vinyl counterparts allow for, I’m left with no choice but to go with the slightly less appealing and sonically compromised Deluxe Edition. Of course, if I had not compared releases, I likely wouldn’t know what I’m missing out on so that perspective needs to be taken into account.
Through, a George Michael original from Patience, is a beautiful song to open the album with and it’s as if it should have always included an orchestra for this live performance trumps the original recording. The strummed introduction, intermingled with vocals and subtle symphonic elements, sets the tone for the entire album and subsequent performances.
My Baby Just Cares For Me is upbeat and jazzy and would do any jazz club in New Orleans proud. The horn section in this song is perfectly balanced and I appreciate this as sometimes the brashness of brass instruments can overpower a song.
A Different Corner slows things down a little with gorgeous vocals and acoustic guitar and bass strumming. It’s a simple and uncomplicated rhythm, but one that highlights Michael’s extraordinary vocal capabilities. Dating back to the mid-80s and the final Wham! release, Music From The Edge Of Heaven, the live performance of A Different Corner captures the soul of the studio recording and is the perfect counterpart to that 1986 release.
Praying For Time was originally released as the lead single on Michael’s second solo album Listen Without Prejudice Vol. 1 and is one of his greatest and most memorable tunes. While the original studio recording is marvellous, in its own right, this live performance takes the song to another level entirely; magnificent!
Let Her Down Easy is a song I adore. It was originally written and recorded masterfully by Terence Trent D’Arby (Sananda Maitreya) on the album Symphony Or Damn. The song is just so soothing, especially as it’s presented in a lullaby style, and Michael performed it beautifully.
The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face is an absolute classic and this live recording represents one of the very best interpretations of the song I have ever had the pleasure of hearing.
Feeling Good is epic! George Michael performs this tune masterfully. That said, I still consider Nina Simone’s version to be the pinnacle recording of this classic song.
John And Elvis Are Dead is a lovely live recording of Michael’s tune; first heard on Patience. While I never considered John And Elvis Are Dead to be a standout song, although it’s a wonderful studio recording, this live performance changes that perspective for it flows so incredibly well within the live album structure that I couldn’t imagine Symphonica without it. Plus, it’s a little more relaxed than the studio release meaning that it can be fully appreciated in a relaxed setting when listening to Symphonica.
Roxanne will appeal to any fan of The Police for this live recording is a beautiful interpretation of their original tune from their 1978 release, Outlandos d’Amour. As solid as the original is, the jazz-influenced live recording by George Michael is exceptional and amplifies the song beyond The Police’s version.
One More Try was originally released on Michael’s highly successful debut solo album Faith and it’s a George Michael classic that remains as fresh today as the day it was written and recorded. This live rendition honours the original studio release perfectly and the addition of the symphonic orchestra is complementary and therefore takes nothing away from the original.
Going To A Town is one of the most beautiful songs ever written and is one of the greatest songs Michael has ever sung for it’s simply stunning and is perfectly suited to Michael’s vocal style. To say that I’m blown away would be an understatement, but if you’re as impressed by this recording as I am, then I suggest you check out Rufus Wainwright’s original from Release The Stars.
Cowboys And Angels is another George Michael original from Listen Without Prejudice Vol. 1. It’s a nice classical meets jazz-styled tune, but it’s the worst song on Symphonica for Michael’s vocal sibilance is far too prominent. Thankfully, the sibilance isn’t a detracting element on the original studio recording, so the song can still be thoroughly enjoyed via that release.
Idol is an underrated Elton John and Bernie Taupin collaboration from John’s 1976 album Blue Moves. This live recording, however, is one of those examples where an artist records a lesser-known cover, makes it their own, and that recording then becomes the standard to which all others are compared.
Brother Can You Spare A Dime is an American Classic and one that George Michael recorded and previously released on Songs From The Last Century. As good as Michael’s studio recording is from 1999, this live interpretation is about as good as it gets. The orchestral elements are off the charts and are not that far removed from Michael’s original interpretation, while Michael’s velvety smooth vocal ensures that Brother Can You Spare A Dime will remain in the social consciousness for decades to come.
You Have Been Loved was originally featured on Michael’s album Older and this live recording doesn’t break any new ground but it remains a lovely ballad with some exceptional jazz drumming and beautiful symphonic elements. That said, this is one case where I prefer the original recording to the live rendition.
Wild Is The Wind has been recorded by some of the greatest musicians the world has ever known, but it really doesn’t matter which version you listen to as Wild Is The Wind is simply gorgeous. That said, Michael’s interpretation is one of, if not the, greatest ever recorded.
You’ve Changed is what I consider to be the perfect closer and, again, I feel the label got the sequencing right when they closed the HFPA Blu-ray Audio version and vinyl releases with this beautiful jazz number as it is reflective and also compels me to listen to the album again.
I Remember You isn’t the strongest closer as it’s rawer, from a production and recording standpoint, than the rest of the songs featured on Symphonica. I also find the harp to be distracting, along with the audience, and subsequently, while I Remember You is included in this review, I remain convinced that the right decision, for me, is to omit it from my digital library, thereby allowing You’ve Changed to close the album out pleasantly.
Overall, sans I Remember You, Symphonica is a powerful and emotionally charged album that showcases George Michael's vocal range and songwriting talent, as well as the beauty and power of a symphony orchestra. Whether you're a fan of George Michael or simply a lover of beautiful music, this live album is worth a listen; you may even add it to your collection, for it is truly remarkable.