Following an album like Goodbye Yellow Brick Road was always going to be a monumental challenge, yet John and the band created an impressively captivating and eclectic musical journey that showcases Elton John's distinct blend of pop, rock, and balladry.
Released in 1974, John’s eighth studio album, Caribou built on the success of his previous releases and continues to highlight the extraordinary writing skills of John and Bernie Taupin; for their ability to craft memorable songs and melodies knew few limits. Yes, it could be said that Caribou isn’t as strong as Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, but if we look at it on its own, Caribou is a masterpiece in its own right; provided, of course, that you ignore the bonus tracks from the 1995 CD remaster. Thankfully, I can choose not to include those songs in my digital library and I’m fortunate to own the 2017 vinyl reissue that is void of bonus material. It's a lovely reissue, particularly sonically as it sounds significantly better than the aforementioned digital remaster with a fuller and more immersive presentation. The album artwork, however, has been reproduced from a scanned source as you get the banding across the cover art that is common with such reproduction processes. The inner sleeve is better produced but could have been a little sharper as the text is easily readable, but the associated photographs are a tad soft. Nevertheless, when a record sounds this good, I’m not going to complain too much about the shortcuts taken with the sleeve designs.
As is common with these reviews, I like to share a version of the stream so that you can listen along while perusing the review. In this case, I’ve created a playlist of the core ten tracks from the album as I feel that’s the best way to experience it. However, if you’re interested in listening to all the bonus tracks, you can check out the complete version here.
The Bitch Is Back is one of the greatest rock songs ever recorded. While John only ever dipped his toe into the hard rock musical spectrum, he could have gone even further for his rockers are just as memorable as his pop tunes and ballads. The song's infectious chorus and driving rhythm make it an instant attention-grabber and is, therefore, the perfect opener for Caribou.
Pinky is tonally beautiful and offers a slight change of pace, moving towards a more introspective and reflective sonic presentation that incorporates John’s signature piano-driven rock sound.
Grimsby has an addictively good rhythm. You’ll be toe-tapping and head-bopping from the very first note. Additionally, the unique tuning of the guitar riff, found throughout, is what can only be described as sonic perfection. I love it!
Dixie Lily is a classic album-only tune, with a touch of country, that would have been better suited for inclusion on Tumbleweed Connection as it feels a little out-of-place on Caribou. That said, after all these years, I can’t imagine Caribou without Dixie Lily.
Solar Prestige A Gammon is a quirky experimental piece that showcases John’s willingness to explore different musical avenues. While it is unlikely to appeal to all music lovers, Solar Prestige A Gammon grows on you the more you listen to it. I, subsequently, consider it a hidden gem.
You're So Static returns us to a more rock-oriented sound. With its energetic instrumentation and catchy chorus, You’re So Static is impossible to resist.
I've Seen The Saucers starts beautifully with a gorgeous beat and atmospheric sound. John’s vocal is somewhat Jazz-inspired and as the song continues its linear flow, it builds into a solid pop/rock tune that is worthy of inclusion on the album. That said, if this song had a little more spit and polish applied, it could have been a massive hit. The result is that there is a masterpiece hidden, just below the surface, that will forever remain concealed. Although, I will say that some of the concealed elements become more apparent on the masterful vinyl reissue.
Stinker leans into a bluesy rock vibe, delivering a gritty and raw musical experience. It’s a fantastic album-only tune and another of John’s many hidden gems.
Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me is simply fantastic and is, arguably, the standout song from Caribou. It’s an emotionally charged ballad and one of John’s greatest vocal recordings. The result is that Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me is an unforgettable masterpiece.
Ticking is another of those hidden gems I’m so fond of. There’s nothing wrong with the core fan-favourite tunes, of course, but John has such diversity in his back catalogue, with so many memorable recordings, that every time I listen to his classic albums, there’s a level of musical freshness to be experienced. That aside, Ticking is a beautiful song that allows for contemplation of the album you’ve just heard while simultaneously compelling you to play Caribou again.
Overall, Caribou showcases John's versatility as the music effortlessly shifts between various styles while maintaining his distinctive flair. The album's diverse range of tracks ensures that there's something for everyone; whether it's energetic rock anthems or heartfelt ballads. While some tracks may stand out more than others, the album as a whole is one of the greatest releases of the 70s and is another snapshot of brilliance from John’s impressive classic era.