While the Bee Gees were already a trio setting the world on fire by the time 1978 rolled around, the Gibb Brothers’ youngest sibling, Andy was forging his own path, one that would ultimately lead to an incredible release, Shadow Dancing; Gibb’s second studio album.
As you listen to Shadow Dancing, you get a sense that this could be an extension of the Bee Gees’ greater catalogue and that wouldn’t be a completely erroneous statement as four of the tracks were written in conjunction with Barry Gibb with the title track also being co-written by Robin and Maurice. Yet, to compare Shadow Dancing to the Bee Gees would be similarly erroneous on the behalf of the music-lover for Andy’s creative output should stand in isolation with nothing more than a tip of the hat for he was a consummate musician and songwriter in his own right. Of course, that isn’t how our minds work so throughout this review you’ll likely come across many correlating aspects.
Musically Shadow Dancing is simply a fun album to listen to and sometimes that is all you need. Yes, the disco-era elements are present but with a touch of pop and soft rock, Shadow Dancing is an album firmly planted in the 70s that will interest all music lovers. Part of the appeal is due to the production of the album, undertaken by the production trio Gibb-Galuten-Richardson (Barry Gibb, Albhy Galuten, and Karl Richardson). While they were only active for approximately 9 years, the trio produced not only all of Andy Gibb’s albums but would also go on to produce Barbra Streisand’s highly regarded and successful album Guilty in 1980.
Sonically, the Lossless Apple Music stream is exquisite. Yes, it is essentially the mastering from the long-out-of-print CD release, but this is a perfect example of if it isn’t broken, don’t fix it. Far too often the music industry reissues and remasters music to varied levels of success. It is with joy that I can mention that Shadow Dancing has never been remastered, to my knowledge at any rate, and I truly hope it stays that way.
Yes, I’d love to see the album reissued on a physical medium, for it has been absent for decades, but a remastering need not apply. A proper CD release would be lovely for the 2013 Japanese re-issue is the only one that I’m aware of that fully replicates the original artwork. The early 90s reissues on Spectrum were atrocious and should be avoided on principle alone. At least, in the modern era, we have access to this classic recording via streaming or digital download stores such as iTunes and the good news is it’s sonically impressive. It’s just a shame the liner notes aren’t included.
Shadow Dancing was the ideal lead single and while it obviously has Bee Gees vibes, as the trio joins Andy with regards to writing this song, it very well could have been a song taken straight from Spirits Having Flown. Subsequently, and needless to say, it’s a masterpiece!
If you’re interested in cover versions, may I suggest you check out the Dee Gees’ recording for The Foo Fighters performance, with Taylor Hawkins on lead vocal, is an incredible homage to this original.
Why is a little more run-of-the-mill when compared to Shadow Dancing, but that often happens when you have an album that opens with such a strong lead track. As with Shadow Dancing, Barry's falsetto vocals can be heard throughout, but is this detrimental or complementary? To be completely honest, I find myself torn on this issue for as exceptional as Andy is, the inclusion of Barry here, and throughout the album, does amplify the recordings; even if it does take the spotlight away from Andy.
Fool For A Night is a hidden gem. Yes, it’s quirky but something is alluring about this particular song that makes me feel it should be considered a standard recording for artists to cover in the decades to come. It just has that laid-back feel that works well within the context of the Great American Songbook.
An Everlasting Love is a great track and the mix and overall arrangement certainly stand out. Granted, An Everlasting Love has a dated sound, but it harks back to the era and therefore hasn’t truly aged. While An Everlasting Love would have been unlikely to have ever set the charts on fire, for it was never released as a single at any rate, it’s songs such as this that make the album experience so enduring.
(Our Love) Don’t Throw It All Away is one of the most beautiful songs ever recorded. Stunning doesn’t come close to describing the sonic brilliance heard here. Most casual fans of the Bee Gees would have heard this before as it was recorded during the Saturday Night Fever recording sessions but not released until 1979 on the Bee Gees’ compilation Greatest. Andy’s version, as heard on Shadow Dancing, would subsequently be the first time the music-loving public would be exposed to this song and his is an admirable performance.
As to which version I prefer, I really can’t choose as they’re both complementary to each other. That said, I do appreciate the additional orchestral elements in the Bee Gees’ recording and the additional vocal layering adds a little more polish that is missing from Andy’s version. That said, I’d go as far as saying that I prefer Andy’s vocal, on this particular song, to Barry’s. Both are enjoyable and worth listening to and when I hear either, I never ponder if the other is better, except for at this moment when I’m actively listening in order to pen my thoughts.
The Bee Gees would also perform the song live, as a tribute to Andy, throughout the One Night Only tour; a recording of which can be heard on the associated live album. While many will lament the use of backing tracks in live performances, this is one instance where it is perfectly suitable for it wasn’t only the Bee Gees that performed this song live as Andy was present, via a backing track, as photos and video of him were shown on the stage screen. It’s a beautiful homage to their brother, who passed away in 1988, and the Bee Gees performed the song masterfully.
Despite a long legacy, with Barry Gibb in particular, Barbra Streisand’s rendition from Guilty Pleasures isn’t the greatest as the song simply isn’t suited to her vocal style. It likely wouldn’t have been a bad recording if Andy or the Bee Gees hadn’t recorded the song first, but it simply doesn’t work when superior recordings exist.
One More Look At The Night is really dated to the era and reminds me of soundtracks from 70s television shows and films, but it’s a great album-only tune!
Melody is the best song on the album, period! Melody should have been released as a single for it’s simply magnificent and I’ve no doubt that it would have reached the top of the charts.
I Go For You has a great mix and is a solid tune. Don Felder’s guitar tracking on this song is thoroughly appreciated as it amplifies an otherwise average song.
Good Feeling is a slow build but you get that good feeling, pun most certainly intended, as soon as the chorus enters into the song structure. It isn’t a stand-out tune, by any means, but it is perfectly positioned within the album’s linear flow.
Waiting For You is a lovely song to close the album on and much like Good Feeling, it would never have been single-worthy material but every song doesn’t need to be a hit to offer an appreciative album experience.
From start to finish, Shadow Dancing is an exceptional release that had it been an album released by the Bee Gees, it would have been an absolute chart topper similar to that of Spirits Having Flown. Of course, it’s never too late and streaming services allow us to enjoy this classic album and there is, therefore, always a chance that Shadow Dancing could still reach the success and recognition it deserves.