An Australian masterpiece ruined by remastering!
Yes, dear reader, Circus Animals is, without a doubt, one of the greatest Australian releases of the 80s, but the 2011 remastered edition makes me want to stop playing the album in disgust. Seriously, it sounds as if the life has been sucked out of the recording. The energy is gone. Barnsey might as well be a pop star from the 60s as much of his vocal grittiness is missing and the entire remastered album sounds so shallow that I’m not sensing a soundstage beyond my speakers. There’s certainly no room-filling sound that ensures their pub-rock legacy is maintained.
Adding insult to injury, Circus Animals is presented as an Apple Digital Master; proving that mastering matters far more than the delivery method for the Apple Digital Master process usually brings out the very best in the recording. Not this time!
I’d turn to Qobuz, but the same mastering can be found there as well, meaning that to fully enjoy this album, I’m going to have to seek out one of the initial vinyl editions, or a pre-remastered CD. While many readers would likely declare that this should have been my first act before penning a review, think for a moment of the new fans, perhaps experiencing Cold Chisel for the very first time, and then suggest to them that they should go and get a beaten up original pressing because the record label, band, and mastering engineer had to reduce the dynamic range, increase the loudness of the recording, thereby making it more fatiguing to listen to.
I just hope that in their infinite wisdom, someone kept, under lock and key, the original first-generation mastering tapes for a future reissue when this type of mastering style comes to an end.
Yes, dear reader, I’ve reflected on the negative thus far but I’ll try to refocus my attention to the music itself for it is truly iconic and deserves to be celebrated nonetheless.
Released in 1982, Circus Animals, Cold Chisel’s fourth studio album, would not only top the charts but would deliver a slew of instant classics. Showcasing Chisel at the height of their creativity, Circus Animals perfectly blends the band’s raw energy, poignant lyrics, and a diverse musical palette while featuring one of the most remarkable ballads ever recorded; When The War Is Over. Of course, Circus Animals is far more than a singular song, so join me as I take a look at the individual songs that make up this landmark release.
You Got Nothing I Want is about as raw as Australian rock and roll gets. The song's catchy chorus, coupled with Barnes' powerhouse vocals, sets a rebellious tone, with a defiant and energetic rhythm, that establishes the album's overall attitude.
Bow River is a blues-infused rock masterpiece. It’s a shame that the mastering is lacklustre because this is not only one of the greatest songs Cold Chisel ever recorded, but it deserves to be turned up to 11 without the dreaded listening fatigue entering the equation.
Forever Now has a beautiful melody and arrangement and while some may prefer Chisel’s harder-hitting hits, Forever Now is an incredible ballad-styled tuned with a sing-a-long chorus that is simply captivating.
Taipan introduces a more experimental and atmospheric sound. The instrumental interplay, tribal rhythm, and dynamic shifts in this track showcase the band's musical dexterity, adding a layer of complexity to the album, thereby demonstrating why they are so revered.
Houndog might well be an album-only tune, but don’t let that deter you as this gritty bluesy number, with its driving rhythm, is exceptional.
Wild Colonial Boy is a solid tune, but while the combination of acoustic and electric elements is appealing, I’d argue that the song is too focused on the storytelling aspects. Granted, some people appreciate music for its literal interpretation, but as someone who considers the human vocal as an instrument in the mix, rather than a storytelling device, I find Wild Colonial Boy to be somewhat disjointed.
No Good For You is a straightforward rock track and hidden gem. The guitar-driven arrangement and Barnes' commanding vocals, along with the backing vocals, are a perfect addition to the album as it has an infectious quality that will stay with you long after the album has ended.
Numbers Fall has a killer synthetic entrance that morphs into a low-toned gritty bluesy masterpiece. With a blend of rock and new wave influences, Chisel further showcased their willingness to experiment with their sound ensuring that Numbers Fall sounds familiar, yet unique.
When The War Is Over is, without doubt, one of the best songs ever written and recorded, by anyone, anywhere. Cold Chisel doesn’t get much better than this! Although, John Farnham’s rendition is spectacular.
Letter To Alan is a fantastic closer that will encourage you to listen to Circus Animals again, but I’d suggest that When The War Is Over would have been a stronger closer.
Remastering issues aside, Circus Animals is a masterful display of the band's musical prowess and artistic depth. While many consider this album to be Chisel’s greatest, perhaps only ever challenged for that position by East, I find that I would have to agree with that perspective for it is primarily hit after hit and plays like a Greatest Hits release, rather than a standard album. From the powerful vocals to the skilful instrumentation and thought-provoking lyrics, this album stands as a testament to Cold Chisel's status as one of Australia's most iconic rock bands. They certainly broke the mould when they chiselled out this masterpiece.