Released in 1973, Hat Trick is amongst the greatest records the folk-rock trio, collectively known as America, ever released. While Hideaway remains my favourite America album, Hat Trick came across my radar around the same time when EMI Australia reissued those records as part of the Legendary Masters series. As such, these two records were my only exposure to America for quite some time, and unlike the modern era, when you purchased an album in the pre-streaming period, you generally listened to it until it melded with your soul. Hat Trick did just that and truth be told, I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve listened to this exceptionally underrated album throughout the years.
Part of the appeal is due to the album’s artwork, which features a photograph within a photograph styling and remains highly appealing. Unfortunately, I’ve only ever experienced it on the CD-sized canvas and despite enjoying the larger size when presented via the Apple TV 4K, this is one record that would look exceptional should one be fortunate enough to own the vinyl release. For those who are interested, Warner Records, in conjunction with Music On Vinyl (MOV), recently reissued Hat Trick in 2021. I’ve no idea what that pressing is like as it flew under my radar at the time. That said, MOV reissues are often amongst the very best reproductions available to vinyl music lovers, so it may well be a consideration.
As with Hideaway, the non-Apple Digital Master CD-quality lossless stream, from Apple Music, is sonically pleasing, so much so that you’ll ponder if you need to seek out a “better” copy. It really is quite lovely, but for those who are looking for even higher resolution options, Qobuz has a 24-bit/192 kHz edition available. Regardless, when an album is recorded, mixed, and mastered this well, format and delivery method matter far less for you’re in for an audible treat that is nothing short of extraordinary.
Perhaps most interesting is that Hat Trick failed to generate significant interest from the music-loving public; particularly considering how well their self-titled debut (January, 1972), and Homecoming (November, 1972) were received. While I’ve no idea why the album failed to be as successful, and Holiday (June, 1974) would see the band regain some ground, I have heard in passing that the record label was not sold on “Muskrat Love” being the lead single, an aspect the band demanded, and hence support upon release was significantly dropped. While I can neither prove nor disprove this possibility, the music industry is littered with similar stories. It’s a shame because Hat Trick is a hidden gem that has rarely been acknowledged outside of the album’s existence within the band’s back catalogue.
Of course, the lack of interest amongst the music-buying public could also be attributed to the slightly more experimental style when compared directly to their first two records. The chosen singles weren’t necessarily the strongest songs from the album and the record is absent of a hit such as “A Horse With No Name”. However, if we consider Hat Trick to be a coherent album experience, then this album knows few peers.
Muskrat Love is a beautifully soft ballad. While the lyrical context is a little whimsical and quite frankly, quirky, it’s a solid tune nonetheless. As the album’s lead single, one can understand why Hat Trick may not have been received as well as the band’s previous releases, but I for one find this song to be a charming addition to America’s catalogue of exceptional music.
Wind Wave has an incredible opener with an evolving sound that builds via its layered production. Dreamy would be one way to describe it for Wind Wave is a moody atmospheric piece that will stay with you long after the album has ended.
She's Gonna Let You Down flows seamlessly from Wind Wave and is absolutely stunning. The lush, yet melancholic, piano-centric tune is a pleasure to the ears, but it’s the vocal delivery and harmonious presentation that’s the ultimate standout in this cinematic-styled tune.
Rainbow Song is an upbeat number that plays into America’s folk roots with vivid imagery. If nothing else, Rainbow Song is a toe-tapping head-bopper that is well-balanced with rich vocal harmonies and jangly musical elements.
Submarine Ladies includes a little psychedelia. To say it’s exceptional would be an understatement for Submarine Ladies is not only perfectly suited to the era, it’s amongst the greatest songs America ever wrote and recorded. There’s also a touch of Glen Campbell's influence to be heard but the soundscape is so multilayered that you’re sure to hear new elements upon each subsequent listen.
It's Life is another hidden gem that has seldom received the recognition it deserves for it’s quintessentially America; albeit with a touch of rock and roll.
Hat Trick is a lovely tune that blends pop sensibilities with America’s harmonious folk origins. It’s an ideal title track and despite a runtime of well over eight minutes, this symphonically experimental tune, with a touch of progressive rock, is amongst the very best timeless recordings in America’s extensive back catalogue. It’s another of those songs that make me question how Hat Trick was overlooked at the time for there isn’t a dull moment to be heard throughout this song or the entire album.
Molten Love is a smooth mid-tempo tune with a touch of R&B to add to the song’s overall warm production, thereby offering a unique blend of folk and soul. While it isn’t a standout, it’s another perfect album-only number that enhances Hat Trick.
Green Monkey is a killer tune and Joe Walsh’s guitar performance amplifies the song as his rock edge works remarkably well with the trio’s harmonious and layered production qualities. Despite being the third, and last, single from Hat Trick, one can’t help but wonder if Green Monkey would have been a far better lead single.
Willow Tree Lullaby is a beautiful acoustic folk-focused ballad that offers a respite from the newer and more experimental pieces for those who would find Hat Trick too far removed from America’s origins.
Goodbye is a perfect closer, one that will compel you to play the album again or stay within America’s impressive discography. No, it isn’t a standout, but every song need not be a hit to make an album thoroughly enjoyable.
Hat Trick is first and foremost an album experience, not just because it lacked a series of killer singles. While it’s a little more experimental and sees the band evolve from their folk-rock origins, it isn’t so far removed that fans, both casual and dedicated, should ignore this release for doing so is to miss out on one of the greatest albums from the 70s, particularly 1973.